Good faith in commercial contracts, Commercial Solicitors Blake Turner LLP London

When can English law imply a duty to act fairly?

In this article we take a look at good faith in commercial contracts. Specifically when and if English law implies a duty to act fairly.

As London based commercial solicitors, we know too well how commercial relationship can deteriorate, and often very quickly indeed.   

A supplier withdraws work that another party expected to receive. A distributor exercises a contractual discretion in a way that appears opportunistic. A shareholder relies strictly on contractual rights despite years of cooperation. Or one party terminates a long-standing agreement in circumstances that appear fundamentally unfair.

The immediate question we hear is often: can they really do that?

English law does not recognise a general principle that parties to commercial contracts must always act in good faith. Nor will a court rewrite a carefully negotiated agreement simply because the outcome appears unfair.

However, in certain circumstances, a duty of good faith may be implied into a commercial contract. The recent High Court decision in Svella Connect Limited v Virgin Media Limited [2026] EWHC 2223 (TCC) provides important guidance on where the courts are likely to draw the line.

For businesses involved in commercial contract disputes, the central question is therefore not simply whether the other party has behaved unfairly. It is whether the contract, properly interpreted under English law, contains an express or implied obligation that restricts that conduct.

Does English contract law recognise a general duty of good faith?

Generally speaking, the answer to this question in short is, no.

Unlike some other legal systems, English law has traditionally been reluctant to impose an overarching duty requiring commercial parties to act fairly or in good faith.

The starting point remains the contract itself. The court will examine what the parties expressly agreed and will generally expect sophisticated commercial parties to be bound by that bargain.

That does not mean good faith is irrelevant. Parties are free to include an express good-faith obligation in their agreement. In more limited circumstances, the court may also imply a term requiring good faith.

What Svella Connect Limited v Virgin Media Limited makes particularly clear is that such an obligation does not arise merely because a court considers a commercial relationship to be collaborative or long term.

What happened in Svella Connect v Virgin Media?

The dispute in this case concerned three framework agreements governing network services and a later Exit & Settlement Agreement.

The framework agreements were detailed commercial contracts. They contained an express obligation for the parties to act “in a spirit of mutual trust and co-operation”, but did not guarantee particular volumes of work.

Virgin Media could seek competitive bids, award work at its discretion and terminate the framework agreements for convenience on 12 months’ notice.   When the parties’ relationship deteriorated, Svella pursued claims that eventually centred on alleged breaches of implied duties of good faith.

The important issue was whether wider good-faith obligations could be implied into the agreements.

The High Court rejected the claim. Critically, the court did not accept that identifying an agreement as a “relational contract” provides an alternative route to imposing good-faith obligations. The orthodox principles governing the implication of contractual terms still have to be satisfied.

That distinction matters.

What is a relational contract?

Good faith arguments sometimes arise in what have become known as relational contracts.  These are typically contracts involving a long-term commercial relationship in which cooperation, communication, trust and ongoing performance can assume particular importance.

Previous cases, including Yam Seng Pte Ltd v International Trade Corporation Ltd [2013] EWHC 111 (QB), helped develop the argument that good-faith obligations might be implied into certain relational contracts. But subsequent decisions have been cautious about treating the label itself as sufficient.

Indeed, the Court of Appeal observed in Candey Ltd v Bosheh [2022] EWCA Civ 1103 that there had been “something of an avalanche” of attempts by claimants to characterise agreements as relational contracts, with relatively few succeeding. Svella Connect Limited v Virgin Media Limited reinforces that cautious approach.

A long commercial relationship does not, by itself, create an implied duty of good faith.

When can a duty of good faith in commercial contracts be implied?

The crucial question is whether the proposed term satisfies the normal test for implying a contractual term.

As the High Court emphasised in Svella Connect Limited v Virgin Media Limited, the established principles of implication, including those considered by the Supreme Court in Marks and Spencer plc v BNP Paribas Securities Services Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd [2015] UKSC 72, remain applicable.  

A court is not asking whether inserting a good-faith obligation would make an agreement fairer.  It is considering whether the term is necessary to give the contract business efficacy or is so obvious that it goes without saying.

The proposed term must also be capable of clear expression and must not contradict an express provision of the contract.  That creates a deliberately high threshold.

Before alleging breach of an implied duty of good faith, a breach of contract solicitor therefore needs to analyse the contract as a whole. That review would include the express obligations, discretions, termination provisions, allocation of commercial risk and the particular term said to be missing.

Good faith in commercial contracts – distribution and long-term supply agreements

The issue can be particularly important in distribution agreements and long-term supply arrangements.

For example, one party may have considerable discretion over:

  • allocation of orders;
  • pricing mechanisms;
  • sales territories;
  • performance targets;
  • approval or consent;
  • renewal;
  • exclusivity;
  • minimum purchase commitments; or
  • termination.

A distributor or supplier may believe that years of cooperation mean the other party cannot suddenly change how such rights are exercised. That conclusion should not be assumed.

Where a detailed contract expressly gives one party a particular right or discretion, an implied good-faith term cannot simply be used to rewrite the bargain.

What about joint ventures and shareholders’ agreements?

Good-faith questions can also become highly significant in joint ventures and shareholder disputes.

These relationships often involve substantial cooperation over many years, while contractual documentation may give shareholders, directors or joint venture partners particular rights and discretions.

When relations break down, one side might argue that a contractual power has been exercised for an improper purpose, opportunistically or contrary to the commercial understanding on which the venture was built.

That does not automatically establish a breach of an implied duty of good faith. The precise wording of the shareholders’ agreement, joint venture agreement, articles, and associated documents needs close analysis.

This is why getting advice from specialist commercial contract solicitors, such as us here at Blake Turner LLP, can be important.

The issue may involve contractual interpretation, implied terms, express duties, contractual discretions and potentially other company or shareholder remedies.

Can good faith in commercial contracts affect termination of the contract?

Termination is a particularly sensitive area.

A party faced with termination may believe the decision is unfair or inconsistent with the history of the commercial relationship. But that does not necessarily make the termination unlawful.

The first question is whether the terminating party has complied with the contractual termination provisions and any requirements imposed by law. A good-faith argument cannot automatically override an express right to terminate.

The position can become more complex where termination depends upon the exercise of a contractual discretion or forms part of a wider course of disputed conduct.

Importantly, the court in Svella Connect Limited v Virgin Media Limited considered it inherently unlikely that a good-faith obligation would be implied into a settlement agreement, which is ordinarily intended to bring a commercial relationship or dispute to an end.

Businesses negotiating exit arrangements should therefore ensure that obligations they expect the other party to observe are expressly documented rather than relying on an assumption that the court will later impose broader duties of fairness.

Your contract doesn’t contain a duty of good faith. Could the court imply one anyway?

Possibly, but Svella Connect Limited v Virgin Media Limited demonstrates that the threshold is high.

The fact that a contract is long term, collaborative or labelled “relational” does not automatically give rise to an implied obligation to act in good faith. The court will start with the wording of the commercial agreement and apply the established legal principles governing implied terms.

Paul Cooper, added “for businesses, there are two practical lessons. Firstly, when negotiating commercial agreements, important expectations about cooperation, conduct, discretion, and good faith should ordinarily be dealt with expressly. Secondly, if a commercial relationship is already breaking down, neither side should assume that the absence of the words “good faith” necessarily ends the analysis, or that apparently unfair conduct automatically creates a claim.

The contractual documents, the nature of the alleged breach and the legal basis of any implied obligation all need to be considered carefully”.

Commercial contract dispute solicitors in London

Blake Turner LLP regularly advises businesses on commercial contracts and disputes arising from contractual relationships, including distribution agreements, shareholder and joint venture arrangements, supply agreements, contractual termination and other complex commercial contract disputes.

If another party is exercising its contractual rights in a way that you believe breaches your agreement, or you are considering termination and want to understand the risk of a subsequent claim, our commercial solicitors in London can advise on the contractual position, potential remedies and the most commercially effective route forward.

Early advice from an experienced contract dispute solicitor can be particularly valuable before terminating an agreement, withholding performance, issuing proceedings, or taking another step that may itself have contractual consequences.

Speak to us. We are Blake Turner LLP’s commercial contract solicitors in London. We help clients with commercial contract disputes, breach of contract or termination and beyond.  A member of the Blake Turner LLP team is waiting to help.

Blake-Turner Commercial Solicitors London, Paul Cooper
Paul Cooper,
Commercial Solicitor,
Blake Turner Solicitors LLP, London